Firing Teachers is Not the Answer
Officials from the Detroit School announced they would close 44 schools. Detroit’s announcement follows others around the country. Kansas City, Missouri, schools decided to shutter failing schools and a Rhode Island school decided to fire all of its teachers in an attempt to make the school better.
To me, it is an overly simplistic answer to a very complex problem. Is the problem solely the teachers’ fault? Do the community, parents and school administrators share the blame? We need to admit that the educational system is broken. The people who regularly read this blog know that. The present educational system is based on a concept designed, with few changes, during the industrial age. In our middle and high schools, we pass children along an assembly line based model that should have been examined and improved a while ago. The system still works for a decreasing number of students but it needs to be revised, modernized and strengthened to meet the needs of the students and the society as well.
For some, the easy answer to any problem is to fire the worker. Were the workers at General Motors and Chrysler responsible for the failure of their companies or was it the people who ran the company? Did Goldman-Sachs, Enron or the banking system failure the fault of the workers or the failure of the bosses?
Rhode Island has one of the highest unemployment rates in the nation. Central Falls is one of the poorest towns in the state. According to Wikipedia, the median income in the town is $22k. More than 96 percent of the Central Falls High School students are eligible for free or reduced lunch, according to the school’s Web site, and only 6 percent of the people in the town have a college degree. The parents and residents of Central Falls are struggling financially and lack postsecondary education to help them seek higher paying jobs.
Does anyone really believe that by firing teachers the lives of the children will improve and that the newly employed teachers will improve test scores and learning?
Teachers are not magicians. They are unable to pull higher test scores and the lower the dropout rate by pulling answers from a hat. They need help from the parents, help from the community, help from the administrators, help from state and federal governments.
According to Education.com, Rhode Island in 2007/2008 spent more money on inmates ($38,503) than on starting teachers ($33,815). But the answer isn’t simply throwing more money on a failing system. Teachers are aware when they enter the field how much they will be paid. They enter the field because they want to help children learn. Data indicate that they do not leave the field mainly because of low pay.
Or take a look at the Chicago Public Schools, where former CEO Arne Duncan, now U.S. secretary of education, closed many schools. There’s been little change in scores because students are being transferred to other low-performing schools. It hasn’t worked because the community’s attitude and level of support hasn’t changed.
Alternatives to Expulsion & Dropping Out of School Conference
| February 2, 2011 | to | February 4, 2011 |
Franklin will be delivering a workshop at the Royal Plaza Hotel in Orlando Florida on the topic, “Tools and Strategies to Stop Students From Dropping Out of School”.
Minority Females Are More Obese Than Whites
While some research suggests that the incidence of childhood obesity may be leveling off, a new study finds that for certain racial groups the rates may actually be getting higher.
A new report to be published in the September issue of Pediatrics, finds that black, Hispanic and American Indian girls have two to three times higher odds of having a high body-mass index (BMI) compared to white girls.
What’s more, although rates of obesity peaked for Hispanic girls in 2005, they have kept on rising for American Indian and black girls.
The researchers reviewed data on more than 8 million fifth-, seventh- and ninth-grade students in California. They found that 38% of the kids were overweight, nearly 20% were obese and 3.6% were severely obese.
The racial disparity was most evident in the highest BMI category. Just 1.3% of white girls fell into this category, but 4.9% of American Indian girls and 4.6% of black girls did, reported the study.
White boys peaked in 2005 and declined to 2001 levels by the end of the study. The rate of obesity dropped in Hispanic and Asian boys after 2005, but hadn’t dropped back to 2001 levels by 2008. There was no increase in the prevalence of obesity in black boys, except in the severely obese category, which peaked in 2007. The rates in American Indian boys peaked in 2007, but declined only in the above 95th percentile group.
In some areas, it’s difficult to regularly find affordable fresh produce, and in some areas, it’s not safe for kids to exercise outside. Sleep can play a role in a child’s weight, Landis said. Young children should get 10 to 11 hours of sleep; school-aged kids need 10 hours; and teens need at least nine hours, she said. Without enough sleep, it may be hard to be active or to make good food choices.
What are the implications for schools? Obesity causes children to become sluggish- unwilling to participate in school activities and worse, more susceptible to diseases like diabetes. It is imperative for school lunches to be healthy and for school activities to involve all students.
Should Mayors Control Schools?
In much of the country, test scores have come down and fewer schools are meeting AYP (Adequate Yearly Progress), This may not be caused by poorer performance but may be because the bars for passing are being constantly raised as a result of the demands of No Child Left Behind. What is more upseting is that the gap in student performance between minority and white children seems to be widening. In New York City, where Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg and his schools chancellor, Joel I. Klein, have control over the city’s schools, the achievement gap which the mayor said that the gap was shrinking, has widened again.
The mayor and chancellor testified before Congress about the city’s impressive progress in closing the gulf in performance between minority and white children. The gains were historic, all but unheard of in recent decades. “Over the past six years, we’ve done everything possible to narrow the achievement gap — and we have,” Mr. Bloomberg testified. “In some cases, we’ve reduced it by half.”
When results from the 2010 tests, which state officials said presented a more accurate portrayal of students’ abilities, were released, they came as a blow to the legacy of the mayor and the chancellor, as passing rates dropped by more than 25 percentage points on most tests. But the most painful part might well have been the evaporation of one of their signature accomplishments: the closing of the racial achievement gap.
Among the students in the city’s third through eighth grades, 40 percent of black students and 46 percent of Hispanic students met state standards in math, compared with 75 percent of white students and 82 percent of Asian students. In English, 33 percent of black students and 34 percent of Hispanic students are now proficient, compared with 64 percent among whites and Asians.
But the latest state math and English tests show that the proficiency gap between minority and white students has returned to about the same level as when the mayor arrived. In 2002, 31 percent of black students were considered proficient in math, for example, while 65 percent of white students met that standard.
The bulk of Mr. Bloomberg and Mr. Klein’s effort to overhaul the education system has been focused on the lowest-performing students. The city has closed 91 poorly performing schools, established about 100 charter schools and sent waves of new young teachers and principals into schools in poor neighborhoods.
The city has even tried to attack the deeper issue of how children are reared at home, by offering some families monetary incentives to go to the dentist for checkups, for example, or to maintain good school attendance. The three-year-old pilot project was ended in March after it showed only modest results.
What has caused the drop in test scores as well as a widening of the educational achievement gaps between whites and minorities? Could it have been caused by poor economic conditions for poor families or an increase in fatherless black households? No body knows. But the real question to my mind is does political control over schools mean school improvement? Is it the magic answer to narrowing the achievement gap? I will let you decide!
More Diane Ravitch
Anyone who reads this blog knows my fondness for the work of Diane Ravitch. IN her latest book, The Death and Life of the Great American School System, Ms. Ravitch, lays out a plan to improve America’s schools. Let me present several to you:
- leave decisions about schools to educators, not politicians or busieness people.
- devise a truly national curriculum that sets out what children in every grade should be learning
- expect charter schools to educate the children who need help the most, and not to compete with public schools
- pay teachers a fair wage for their work, not “merit pay” based on deply flawed and unreliable test scores.
- encourage family involvement in education from an early age.
I believe that the ideas listed above provide a basis for discussion. What do you think about them?
Identifying Quality After-School Programs
|
Program Quality Matters for Adolescent Outcomes
A new Child Trends research brief finds positive outcomes for adolescents in high-quality out-of-school time programs, but no significant differences between adolescents in low-quality programs and those not in a program at all. The brief, How Out-of-School Time Program Quality is Related to Adolescent Outcomes, is based on data from the Every Child Every Promise survey commissioned by the America’s Promise Alliance. For adolescents ages 12-17, it also finds:
11.5 percent are not in a program, 11.4 percent are in a low-quality program, 45.4 percent are in a medium-quality program, and 31.7 percent are in a high-quality program.
Adolescents in low-quality programs have similar outcomes to adolescents in no program.
Adolescents in medium-quality programs have better school performance than those not in a program, but do not have significantly fewer risky behaviors or significantly greater social competence.
Adolescents in high-quality programs are more likely to avoid risky behaviors, to have better performance in school, and to have greater social competence, than those in no program, even taking account of confounding factors.
High-quality out-of-school time programs are defined as those that promote a sense of physical and emotional safety, enable youth to build positive relationships, allow youth a role in decisions, and support development of social skills, like conflict resolution, leadership, and teamwork.
National Conference on Alternative Education – Nashville
| February 9, 2011 8:00 pm | to | February 12, 2011 8:00 pm |
Franklin will be presenting two workshops for the National Alternative Education Association (NAEA) www.the-naea.org) in Nashville, TN.
“Helping Students Graduate: Strategies and Tools to Help Raise Graduation Rates and Lower Dropout Rates” and “What Do Successful Leaders of At-Risk Learners Do To Raise Academic Performance and Improve School Cultures”
America Needs More College Graduates
A new report from Georgetown University’s Center on Education and the Workforce states that the United States’ colleges and universities will need to inccrease by 10% the number of degrees they confer in order to meet the workforce’s education requirements by 2018. According to the report, 63% of jobs in the U.S. economy will require some education beyond high school. This is an increase from 59% in 2008. The report also state that just 19 states will be at that level. Jobs for high school graduates will be concentrated in Southern states. For state-by-state comparisons visit: cew.georgetown.edu
It would appear to me that in order to meet those requirements, states need to increase the number of students graduating from K-12 schools. Therefore we should have some sort of cooperation between K-12 schools and univrsities to align what we are doing.
Do We Really Need Grades?
What is the purpose of giving grades?
The Mount Olive school district, in New Jersey has eliminated the grade od “D’ from its report cards.
“D’s are simply not useful in society,” said Larrie Reynolds, the Mount Olive superintendent, who led the campaign against D’s as a way to raise the bar and motivate students to work harder. “It’s a throwaway grade. No one wants to hire a D-anything, so why would we have D-students and give them credit for it?”
The no-D policy was adopted by the school board. Even some teachers have expressed concerns that it may result in more students failing and possibly dropping out of school.
How many of us knowingly would go to a “D” doctor or fly on a n airplane piloted by a “D” pilot? Should we allow students to pass a subject with a “D”?
Under the old system, students could pass with a 65 — 389 of the 1,500 students at Mount Olive High had a “D” on their final report cards in June — but now anything lower than a 70 will be considered failure.
While few high schools have banned D’s outright as Mount Olive has, some have sought to tamp down grade inflation by quietly tightening their standards over the years. Several New Jersey high schools, for instance, have raised the minimum for D’s to 70, which is traditionally the C-minus range, with anything below deemed an F.
Mount Olive, an above-average school in a middle-class community, is developing a support system to help students meet the tougher grading standard. When students receive a failing grade on a test, a paper or a homework assignment in the future, they will have three days to repeat the work for a C, and their parents will be notified by phone or e-mail.
Students who continue to fail will be placed on a “watch list” to receive extra-help classes, as well as tutoring from other students. If they need to make up a failed course, they will be given the option of attending an evening school, known as “Sunset Academy,” that will charge a fee of $150 per class.
While I commend the superintendent and school board of Mount Olive, I believe that we should limit grades to three, pass, exceptional and “no credit”. It is increasingly difficult to explain to students and parents the difference between a 89 and a 90. In New York City, where I taught, some teachers gave a student a zero (0) what effect did that have on a student? Grades need to reflect achievement, not effort. A student who says, “I deserve to pass because I tried hard” doesn’t deserve to pass unless the student achieves a certain teacher-established competency in a subject.
Does Merit Pay for Teachers Work?
The business and political community believe that if you give merit pay to educators to produce higher test scores there will be an improvement in academic achievement.
According to a new study conducted by Vanderbilt University in Nashville Tennessee giving bonuses of up to $15,000 did not produce higher test scores. The study was conducted from 2006 to 2009 and involved 296 middle school math teachers. The teachers were placed in two pools what were randomly selected. One-third of the eligible teachers -51 out of 152 – got bonuses at least once. Except for some temporary gains, their students progressed no faster than those in classes taught by the 146 other teachers.
Critic
